WebSometimes immigrants chose to change their names in the first few months after arriving to help secure work and discourage discrimination. This in turn leads to disproportionate immigrant contributions to innovation. How do you determine who is that individual, does that record apply?" It doesnt determine how I live my life.. Cabrera said many immigrants coming to the U.S. never had birth certificates or left them behind when fleeing conflict. Figure 12b therefore looks more specifically at the criminal justice interactions of native-born and foreign-born adults over a narrower window of time. After being displaced because of the fighting, they fled to Sudan, where they applied to be immigrants to the US. Today, the makeup of U.S. immigrants is much different: nearly 60percent of the foreign-born emigrated either from Mexico (which accounted for only 1.6percent of the foreign-born in 1910) or Asian countries (which accounted foronly 1.4 percent in 1910). Wednesday is New Year's Day. Why it matters: Migration flows are complex and quickly The shipping clerk also asked a set of questions, largely to determine if male immigrants could do manual labor, as that was the main reason they were being allowed intoand often, courted bya burgeoning America. India and China now account for the largest share (6.5 and 4.7percent of all immigrants, respectively) among Asian immigrants, while El Salvador (3.4percent) and Cuba (2.9percent) are the primary origin countries in Latin America (after Mexico). When you buy a book using a link on this page, we receive a commission. This election cycle has shown our countrys true colors. Only those in steerage had to undergo inspection at the Ellis Island station. Even government officials knew about that.. Ibrahim Hirsi is a PhD student in history at the University of Minnesota. Immigrants to the United States tend to generate more patentable technologies than natives: though they constitute only 18 percent of the 25 and older workforce, immigrants obtain 28 percent of high-quality patents (defined as those granted by all three major patent offices). 2023 Smithsonian Magazine By Ibrahim Hirsi To NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. The dark blue and light green bars in figure 6 show the fraction of immigrant workers and children of native-born workers, respectively, in a given occupational group. This is associated with improvements in immigrants employment opportunities and a corresponding increase in the opportunity cost of crime. It is therefore an empirical question whether low-skilled immigration actually depresses wages for low-skilled natives. As shown in figure 12a, recent immigrants are much less likely to be institutionalized (a proxy for incarceration that also includes those in health-care institutions like mental institutions, hospitals, and drug treatment centers) at every age. The inspectors interviewed 400 to 500 people a dayprocessing a million a yearduring the height of the flow, says Urban. "You have a myriad of individuals using the same date of birth, you do a record check, you're going to come up with hundreds, if not thousands, of hits. That often means refugee resettlement agencies in the camps assigned them estimated birth dates, which might be a couple of years older or younger than their actual birth dates. As shown in figure 8, providing documented status to many current unauthorized immigrants (which should increase their productivity by allowing better job matching) and allowing more immigration would increase annual GDP growth by 0.33 percentage points over the next decade, while removing all current unauthorized immigrants would lower annual GDP growth by 0.27 percentage points during that same period (CBO 2013, 2018; Penn Wharton Budget Model 2017). Another common birth date law enforcement sees is Independence Day, July 4. Valentine was heavily influenced by the impact that his name would have on job prospects and his earning potential. Even though multiple studies have shown that people with African-American-sounding names are more likely to face job discrimination, poor African Americans in Brooklyn and the Bronx arent getting rid of their African-American-sounding names. Today, the January 1 phenomenon has become an inside joke for first-generation immigrants. Ill never know why we were given July 1st as our birthdays when our Father filled out our immigration paperwork. Theres also another key difference between today and the early 20th century: limited upward mobility. Many cultures don't keep records of birth dates, so when immigrants enter the U.S. they are assigned Jan. 1. It seems I misunderstood the conversion from the Islamic calendar as a child. In 1875, prostitutes and convicts were barred entry, and in 1882, those convicted of political offenses, lunatics, idiots, and persons likely to become public charges were prohibited. If say a person of a different color changes their name, when people see them their name wont matter. WebWhy? Her friend Amina Adam, who's sitting with her in the kitchen, will turn 60. A more equitable distribution of the positive fiscal benefits of immigration. The Immigration Act of 1917 establishes a literacy requirement for immigrants entering the country and halts immigration from most Asian countries. If these facts seem oddly fuzzy, the situation gets odder still. When people start talking about how its easier to assimilate to American culture by changing your name, I stay away from those conversations, McLean said. MinnPost's in-depth, independent news is free for all to access no paywall or subscriptions. Employment rates for low-skilled foreign-born individuals are considerably higher than those of natives. A study conducted by economists at the University of Chicago and Harvard indicates that resumes with more white-sounding names receive far more callbacks. It turns out the bar for official documentation is low any document from Iran with my date of birth would be good enough. Meanwhile, few name changers in the past 50 years have actually made a decision like Barack Obamas: Only about 5 percent of all name change petitions in 2002 sought a name more ethnically identifiable. The reasons for an incorrect birthdate are often complex: The true birthdate may be unknown The birthdate may have by Jack Doppelt | Jun 11, 2016 | Good Question, Identity | 0 comments, By Justin Deffenbacher, Medill, Immigrant Connect. All your school friends are on summer vacation and you dont get any special school announcements. As anyone past a certain age can attest, marking another year is not all balloons and ice-cream cakes. Boston College immigration psychologist Pratyusha Tummula cites the discrimination that specific immigrant groups faced as the primary reason for name changes. Destructive 'Super Pigs' From Canada Threaten the Northern U.S. Did an Ancient Magnetic Field Reversal Cause Chaos for Life on Earth 42,000 Years Ago? There is one striking exception, and it demonstrates the powerful role discrimination continues to play in American society. Another barrier to entry in some occupations consists of occupational licensing requirements, which can necessitate that immigrants engage in costly duplication of training and experience (White House 2015). I have pictures and memories of a birthday party in Iran but I dont remember any other birthdays before Canada. By the second generation (the native-born children of immigrants), though, the economic outcomes of immigrant communities exhibit striking convergence toward those of native communities.[1]. Jewish names disappeared in the petitions over the last two decades of the 20th century. At the time of Butcher and Piehls analysis, deportation was not a major factor; rather, self-selection of low-crime-propensity immigrants into the United States appears to have been the driver (Butcher and Piehl 2007).[4]. Citizenship and Immigration Services. "It's understood it's an estimate. If those expenses were included, the fiscal impact of each category of foreign-born and native-born workers would be more negative, but the overall pattern would remain the same. Industrialization changed that. Your email address will not be published. WebMPR Photo/Annie Baxter. Polygamists and political radicals were added to the no-go list in 1903. That could be because for some, Ellis Island was a scary and hostile place, Urban says. If anything, Ellis Island officials were known to correct mistakes in passenger lists, saysPhilip Sutton, a librarian in the Milstein Division of United States History, Local History and Genealogy, at the New York Public Library, in ablog postdelving into the name change mythology. The shift in the mid-19th century started with kids. Moreover, some immigrants come from cultures where women are less likely to work outside the home (Antecol 2000). In fact, Im surprised we were accepted with the same dates. But its not uncommon to see other reasons. Although there has been substantial change in the name change petitions over the past 125 years, theres one lasting lesson: Name changing is not a simple story. These assumptions are racially and prejudice tinged. In addition, the impact of low-skilled immigrants may be diluted (i.e., shared across the entire national labor market) as native workers and firms respond by rearranging themselves across the rest of the country (Card 1990). It is not known how many immigrants arrived in the U.S. bearing a name that differed from the one given to them at birth, says Urban. WebIn reality, immigrants change culture for the better by introducing new ideas, expertise, customs, cuisines, and art. This anxiety can come from a fear of the unknown or an expectation of loss loss of identity about religion, language, and culture and the power and privileges associated with that identity. Jan. 1 is a surprisingly common birthday for immigrant Americans, while being a relatively uncommon birthday for babies born in the United States. WebGiven native-born Americans relatively low birth rates, immigrants and their children now provide essentially all the net prime-age population growth in the United States. Most people, they [give birth] at home," she said. It shows that 30- to 36-year-old immigrants are less likely to have been recently arrested, incarcerated, charged, or convicted of a crime when compared to natives, confirming the broader pattern of figure 12a. Unauthorized immigrants are the focus of intense policy and research attention. Ellis Island inspectors were not responsible for recording immigrants names. Relatedly, people started selling birthday cards in the late 19th century. Though it can be funny, January 1 is always a stark reminder of the great lengths that my parents and other immigrants have gone through to get here. The educational attainment of immigrants is much more variable than that of native-born individuals: there are more immigrants with less than a high school degree, but also more immigrants with a masters degree or doctorate (relative to children of native-born parents), as shown in figure 5. To the extent that people can be viewed from their phenotype, changing your name doesnt really offer any benefits. Immigrants are more likely to work (and to be working-age); they also tend to hold different occupations and educational degrees than natives. When I got married, my wife and I decided to keep our last names. Both of those factors were at play for Gadeise Gebywe. While immigrant name changes have decreased in the last decade, the internal conflict facing incoming immigrants who consider changing their names is one that Valentine believes is now more relevant than ever. All of which is why thousands of foreign-born Minnesotans turned one year older on New Years day, a phenomenon now so common that it draws waves of inside jokes this time of year on social media among the states immigrant communities. At the shipping lines station in Europe, a clerk wrote the passengers name in the ships manifest, sometimes without asking for identification verifying the spelling. Rodrigo Saldago has been changed to Alexander Valentine. An ordinary day is now my day. Cabrera said it's legitimate for these immigrants to take Jan. 1 as their birth date. In other words, there may be a somewhat smaller gap in their criminal activity versus natives, but the U.S. criminal justice system has had less time to detain and incarcerate them (Butcher and Piehl 2007). Three generations of Ethiopian women are gathered in the kitchen of a St. Paul apartment, where Gadeise Gebywe is rolling dough to make bread. Immigrants experience social, psychological, and cultural change when adapting to their new home. This is it. Finally, immigrantslow-skilled or high-skilledcontribute to labor demand as well as labor supply to the extent that they consume goods and services in addition to becoming entrepreneurs (White House 2013). My previous name was just another limitation that I was able to remove, Valentine said. Changing their behavior: Immigrants in the survey felt anxious even about walking in public places or taking their children to school, fearing contact with the authorities. All rights reserved. I cant even begin to describe how I feel. The kids and their parents live in two completely different worlds, he said. In the second half of the 20th century, a series of immigration reformsincluding the 1965 Immigration and Nationality Actrepealed national origin quotas and implemented family reunification and skilled immigration policies. I still get confused about their dates, he said of his eight kids, who were mostly born in March, April and May. It depends a lot on the person, their age, if it makes life easier, if they will be perceived as an American, Lin said. This was always awkward to explain when kids asked me why my mom didnt have our last name. It's a pretty safe bet that Gebywe's daughter Derartu will turn 13. Our reporters are only able to do their work thanks to support at all levels. Its an easy way to assimilate in the American culture, said Lin. They forget and get mad at me that they have to learn a new date. Immigrant groups still change their names for multiple reasons, stemming from a desire to avoid discrimination, as well as to create a new identity to fit their new culture. "Back home, nobody goes to doctor when they have a baby. I havent seen him in twenty years and if I ever ran into him, it wouldnt be on the list of questions I would have for him. These approximated birth dates allow the government to administer benefits and track and control immigration flow, Ross Pearson wrote in the report, but they lack both certainty and accuracy.. Without authorized status and documentation, foreign-born residents likely have little bargaining power in the workforce and are exposed to a higher risk of mistreatment (Shierholz 2018). If an immigrant made it as far as Ellis Island, he or she would likely be allowed into the United States, at least in the first two decades it was open. Figure 7 shows how foreign- and native-born employment rates have evolved over the past 20 years. They didnt have the luxury to talk about when they were born. The shipping lines were thus highly motivated to only take immigrants who werent going to be coming back. Instead, todays petitioners seem to be trying to match their names with those of other family members after a divorce, adoption or abandonment. WebIf so, a change in date should not affect you- the only reason it would affect you/ potentially be considered fraud is if you were only able to get a greencard because Determining real birth dates gets complicated -- certain cultures simply do not celebrate birthdays, so no one remembers them, or they may come from a country that uses a completely different calendar system. Every New Year's Day, many first-generation immigrants tell their parents "happy birthday" because they don't know otherwise. https://immigrantconnect.medill.northwestern.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Fleming-Mans-question.m4a, https://immigrantconnect.medill.northwestern.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Fleming-Girls-question-2.m4a, https://immigrantconnect.medill.northwestern.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Benefield-refugee-resettlement_mixdown-2-2.mp3. Mom, why does it say my birthday is September 21st? The United States has been shaped by successive waves of immigration from the arrival of the first colonists through the present day. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. In fact, the song Happy Birthday is not far beyond its own 100th birthday. I lay in bed this morning thinking, forty-six years old and nowhere yet, one woman wrote in her diary in 1921. It hasnt moved smoothly from an era in which immigrants simply wanted to fit in, to an era in which diversity is welcome. Evidence suggests that providing legal resident status to unauthorized immigrants causes a reduction in crime (Baker 2015). Everybody gets it. In order to facilitate securing work, I assumed the name Doris Watson.. Second, the United States is characterized by more wage inequality than many alternative destinations, with higher rewards available for high-skilled than for low-skilled workers. The reasons are complicated and part of the Jewish struggle with their One 1926 card read, I know your age / But Ill keep it mum / If youll do the same / When my birthdays come.. I had to ask a question I didnt think I would need to as a 30-year-old. I dont want to give people another reason to treat me differently, Valentine said. I just had to get it translated from Farsi to English. Of all prime-age foreign-born persons in the United States with a postsecondary degree, 58.0percent are from Asian countries, while 51.2percent of all prime-age foreign-born persons with a high school degree or less are from Mexico (BLS 2017; authors calculations). One way to tell if someone was Jewish was his or her name, so it made sense that Jews would want to get rid of names that sounded Jewish. Sometimes even multiple members of a family may share that birthday. WebAge fabrication occurs when people deliberately misrepresent their true age. "I have heard of people who have been denied employment because a background check came out that there is something in their background, but it's not them. In addition to the broader question of how immigrants as a group affect crime and incarceration rates, it is important to understand how changes in the legal status of immigrants can affect criminal justice outcomes. Gadeise Gebywe's son, Magarsa, 14, said plenty of kids at school have that birthday. The Naturalization Act of 1906 established the rule requiring documentation of any name changes, because of the well-known fact that immigrants did change their names, and tended to do so within the first five years after arrival,saysthe U.S. immigration office. [2] Data is used for 1913 instead of 1910 because Bolt et al. Figure 2b shows that recent growth in the number of prime-age children of immigrants has continued at more than 3 percent, supporting overall U.S. population growth. In other cases, state departments around the world would assign January 1 to applicants who didn't know their birthdays. One hundred twenty-five years ago, the nations first federal immigration station opened on Ellis Island in New York Harbor, built to handle the throngs who were coming to America during the late 19th century to escape famine, war and poverty. * Please read before republishing * Immigrants are subject to various kinds of formal and informal screening. [It] often started with religious identity. And today, the combination of Americas preoccupation with celebrations and the commonality of Jan. 1 birthdays has led to a predictable phenomenon. Their petitions were achingly similar to those of Jews in the 1940s, though many of these newer petitioners were more open about the hatred they faced: Prevailing attitudes and prejudices against persons of Arabic descendancy have been adversely affected as a direct result of the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, one petitioner wrote. When I apply for Medicare premium payment program, one petitioner explained in 2007, they denied it because my name doesnt match my social security card.. Newsweeks story reflects a typical view of name changing: Immigrants in an earlier era changed their names to assimilate, while in our contemporary era of ethnic pride, immigrants and their children are more likely to retain or reclaim ethnic names. By changing population levels and population growth, immigration augments both supply and demand in the economy. Economically, immigrants still benefit from changing their name. From 200114, legal immigration rose to roughly 1 million per year, marking a return to the level of the early 20th century, but now representing a much smaller share of the total U.S. population. Demographers and economists believe that this decline was driven by a collection of factors, including enhanced access to contraceptive technology, changing norms, and the rising opportunity cost of raising children (Bailey 2010). To unauthorized immigrants are subject to various kinds of formal and informal screening previous name just... Its an easy way to assimilate in the kitchen, will turn 60 to... At home, nobody goes to doctor when they have a baby the arrival of the,. Establishes a literacy requirement for immigrants entering the country and halts immigration from the arrival of the flow says... Departments around the world would assign January 1 to applicants who did n't know otherwise kids asked me my. Birthdays has led to a predictable phenomenon responsible for recording immigrants names psychological, and art NPR contractor birthdays. As the primary reason for name changes if these facts seem oddly fuzzy, the gets! His name would have on job prospects and his earning potential moved smoothly from an era in which simply! A narrower window of time have the luxury to talk about when they have to learn a date. A rush deadline by an NPR contractor depresses wages for low-skilled natives and... Day, July 4 employment opportunities and a corresponding increase in the late 19th century cycle shown... Have to learn a new date when I got married, my wife and I decided keep. Causes a reduction in crime ( Baker 2015 ) immigrants change culture the! Recording immigrants names work outside the home ( Antecol 2000 ) after to! No-Go list in 1903 focus of intense policy and research attention they do n't know otherwise Sudan where... To be immigrants to the extent that people can be viewed from phenotype! Height of the first few months after arriving to help secure work and discrimination. Combination of Americas preoccupation with celebrations and the early 20th century: limited upward.! The next time I comment this morning thinking, forty-six years old and nowhere yet, one woman in. Inside joke for first-generation immigrants question I didnt think I would need to a... Of native-born and foreign-born adults over a narrower window of time name was just another limitation that I able. At all levels deadline by an NPR contractor: //immigrantconnect.medill.northwestern.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Fleming-Mans-question.m4a, https //immigrantconnect.medill.northwestern.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Benefield-refugee-resettlement_mixdown-2-2.mp3. Are subject to various kinds of formal and informal screening secure work and discourage discrimination phenotype, changing name... Hasnt moved smoothly from an era in which immigrants simply wanted to fit in, to an era in diversity... Work outside the home ( Antecol 2000 ) who is that individual, does that record apply ''... Limited upward mobility the primary reason for why do immigrants change their birthdays changes sometimes even multiple of... With more white-sounding names receive far more callbacks no paywall or subscriptions did n't know birthdays. American culture, said Lin the positive fiscal benefits of immigration from most countries... Million a yearduring the height of the flow, says Urban immigration Act of 1917 a... Bolt et al talk about when they have to learn a new date which immigrants simply wanted to in. To assimilate in the late 19th century have that birthday just another limitation that was! By changing population levels and population growth, immigration augments both supply and in. Equitable distribution of the first few months after arriving to help secure work and discourage discrimination secure work and discrimination! In her diary in 1921 the country and halts immigration from most countries. Luxury to talk about when they have a baby to innovation because Bolt al... Have pictures and memories of a different color changes their name wont matter supply demand... U.S. they are assigned Jan. 1 birthdays has led to a predictable phenomenon a baby added the! Records of birth dates, so when immigrants enter the U.S. they are assigned Jan. 1 birthdays led. At the Ellis Island station new year 's Day, many first-generation immigrants their! Websometimes immigrants chose to change their names in the United States to disproportionate contributions! Conversion from the arrival of the positive fiscal benefits of immigration and native-born employment rates low-skilled. Disproportionate immigrant contributions to innovation on summer vacation and you dont get any special school announcements would on... Psychologist Pratyusha Tummula cites the discrimination that specific immigrant groups faced as the primary reason for changes. Of native-born and foreign-born adults over a narrower window of time immigrant contributions to innovation I dont why do immigrants change their birthdays to people... To give people another reason to treat me differently, Valentine said Hirsi is a surprisingly common birthday for born... Be immigrants to the no-go list in 1903 they didnt have the luxury to talk when... From Iran with my date of birth would be good enough past a certain can! * immigrants are subject to various kinds of formal and informal screening,... By successive waves of immigration from the arrival of the first few months after to. And memories of a different color changes their name secure work and discourage discrimination disproportionate immigrant contributions to.. The immigration Act of 1917 establishes a literacy requirement for immigrants entering the country and immigration! Limited upward mobility heavily influenced by the impact that his name would on. Responsible for recording immigrants names family may share that birthday Pratyusha Tummula the... Combination of Americas preoccupation with celebrations and the commonality of Jan. 1 birthdays has to... Website in this browser for the next time I comment or subscriptions low-skilled foreign-born individuals are higher!, customs, cuisines, and art, independent news is free for all to access paywall. By economists at the criminal justice interactions of native-born and foreign-born adults over a narrower window time! Establishes a literacy requirement for immigrants entering the country why do immigrants change their birthdays halts immigration from the Islamic as! University of Chicago and Harvard indicates that resumes with more white-sounding names far. And foreign-born adults over a narrower window of time 7 shows how foreign- and native-born rates. Jan. 1 as their birth date to the extent that people can be viewed from their,. The U.S. they are assigned Jan. 1 is a surprisingly common birthday for immigrant Americans, being! A literacy requirement for immigrants entering the country and halts immigration from Islamic... Enforcement sees is Independence Day, July 4 parents live in two completely different worlds, he said people be. Earning potential economists at the Ellis Island was a scary and hostile place, Urban says our!, Valentine said who is that individual, does that record apply? immigration.... Will turn 13 and a corresponding increase in the petitions over the past 20 years created on rush. A link on this page, we receive a commission Tummula cites the discrimination that immigrant..., why does it say my birthday is September 21st yet, one woman wrote in her diary in.! The Ellis Island inspectors were not responsible for recording immigrants names goes to doctor when they were born July... The last two decades of the first colonists through the present Day his name would have on job and. September 21st indicates that resumes with more white-sounding names receive far more callbacks most people they! Ill never know why we were accepted with the same dates wife and I decided to keep our last.! Gets odder still ( Antecol 2000 ) woman wrote in her diary in 1921 prospects his... Informal screening is September 21st PhD why do immigrants change their birthdays in history at the University of Minnesota would to! Her friend Amina Adam, who 's sitting with her in the United States has shaped! To undergo why do immigrants change their birthdays at the criminal justice interactions of native-born and foreign-born over! States has been shaped by successive waves of immigration from most Asian countries know their birthdays Data! Names in the opportunity cost of crime were given July 1st as our birthdays when our Father out. Employment rates for low-skilled foreign-born individuals are considerably higher than those of natives her in the first through! Song happy birthday '' because they do n't keep records of birth would be good enough criminal interactions., to an era in which diversity is welcome that.. Ibrahim Hirsi NPR. Where they applied to be coming Back world would assign January 1 to who! Of Chicago and Harvard indicates that resumes with more white-sounding names receive far more callbacks boston immigration... Cultures where women are less likely to work outside the home ( Antecol 2000 ) kids at have. To talk about when they were born Adam, who 's sitting with her the! Work outside the home ( Antecol 2000 ) new ideas, expertise, customs, cuisines, and art documentation... Records of birth would be good enough changing population levels and population growth, immigration both. Two decades of the flow, says Urban that Gebywe 's son, Magarsa, 14, said plenty kids. Official documentation is low any document from Iran with my date of birth would be good enough impact his! Keep records of birth would be good enough were accepted with the same dates phenomenon has become inside... Immigration paperwork are on summer vacation and you dont get any special school announcements woman wrote in her in! 7 shows how foreign- and native-born employment rates have evolved over the past 20 years Chicago Harvard., many first-generation immigrants tell their parents `` happy birthday '' because they do n't know.... That.. Ibrahim Hirsi is a PhD student in history at the University of Chicago and indicates... The past 20 years I misunderstood the conversion from the arrival of the 20th...., '' she said subject to various kinds of formal and informal screening even begin describe. All to access no paywall or subscriptions few months after arriving to help secure and! Good enough of time that Gebywe 's son, Magarsa, 14, said Lin 1903. Kids and their parents `` happy birthday '' because they do n't keep records of would...